Practice Guide · Civil discovery and procedure, Florida and federal
Preservation and lost evidence
Florida and federal
The law in brief
The duty to preserve generally attaches when litigation is reasonably anticipated. For electronically stored information that should have been preserved and is lost, both systems draw the same line: measures no greater than necessary to cure prejudice, and the harshest remedies (an adverse presumption or instruction, dismissal or default) only on a finding of intent to deprive (Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.380; Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(e)).
Practice points
- The overwrite clock is real: looping security video, disappearing-message settings, device trade-ins and cloud trash windows. Send preservation requests early for anything on a loop.
- A preservation letter to a nonparty is a request, not a command; it starts the record, and a subpoena follows once there is a case.
- Tell the client in writing to suspend deletion and keep devices: the client's own deletion is the most common source of a spoliation fight.
On DraftCounsel
The authorities to read
- Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.380held from one official publisher (April 1, 2026)
- Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(e)held from the official publisher and a reference publisher (United States Code, Title 28 Appendix)
Cited, not quoted: read each in its current official text before relying on it. Each line states exactly the basis the corpus holds the authority on; a cited-only authority gains no claim here.
The client handout
Keeping your evidence safe: the plain-language version you can send your own client.
Source notes
Rewritten for counsel from TrialVector's Learn Center curriculum. The rules are the ones DraftCounsel's Discovery Command runs on for the forum; they are cited, not quoted. DraftCounsel's corpus holds the Florida rules from The Florida Bar's compilations and the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure from the United States Code where Cornell's Legal Information Institute prints the same words; a federal rule the two word differently is cited and not held.