DraftCounsel · Reference · release 2026.11.16
Review desk: capabilities and limits
A grounded review of a document against real exemplars of its kind, delivered as findings the attorney adjudicates one by one.
The desk itself lives at /workspace/review (launcher: /pro-review). Nothing on this page changes what the desk does; it describes it, dated by the release that generated it.
A walkthrough (fictional)
Fictional matter — demonstration: Invented names and facts; nothing here is a real client, party, court or filing.
Every name, party, court and matter below is invented for illustration.
- The fictional firm Harrow & Vale LLP opens the sample matter for its invented client Meridian Data Systems, LLC and attaches the counterparty's draft Mutual NDA from Harbor Analytics, Inc..
- The desk pins five exemplar NDAs of the same kind and venue, compares the draft against their practice, and returns findings: one-way confidentiality, an indefinite term, an automatic injunction with a bond waiver, no return-or-destroy mechanics.
- The reviewing attorney approves, rejects or revises each finding with a reason code; nothing is finalized until every finding carries a decision.
- The Review Certificate derives from the decision trail; it cannot claim a review that did not happen.
Mechanisms
- The exemplar spine: five pinned exemplars of the same kind, hashed and dated, ground every finding.
- The Opposing Counsel Pass runs on every review; every objection becomes a finding.
- The similarity and party guards refuse output that copies or leaks the exemplars.
- The adjudication rail records each decision append-only, with the reviewer's authenticated identity.
- Approval semantics: Each finding takes one decision at a time (approve, reject, revise); a later decision on the same finding supersedes it in the trail, never by editing it.
- Approval semantics: A finding decision never approves the artifact: rejecting an edit is never mistaken for approving the work product.
- Approval semantics: Nothing finalizes with a required finding undecided; every required finding carries a decision first.
- Approval semantics: The artifact is approved by one recorded attorney decision on its exact version; a second decision on that version loses to the first.
- Approval semantics: A new version starts ready for review; the earlier approval is history, never authority for the new version.
- Approval semantics: Only an approved version exports, and its receipt binds the exact bytes once; a refund, a revoked grant or a removed role during the export leaves no receipt and no delivery.
Limits
- Findings are analysis for professional judgment; the desk decides no law.
- A document type with no live exemplar lane is refused, not reviewed from imagination.
- A scanned PDF with no text layer is refused until read through the OCR lane (when the deployment has it on, with per-page confidence and an explicit unreadable state), photographed or pasted as text.
- A document naming none of the matter's parties, or only a namesake, stops the run until the attorney decides by name whether it belongs; nothing is merged for them.
Always stops for a person (the autonomy floor)
- Nothing is sent to anyone outside the platform without a person choosing to send it. (minimum: person)
- No share link leaves without a person minting it for a named recipient. (minimum: person)
- No artifact is finalized without an attorney’s recorded decision on its exact version. (minimum: attorney)
- No final packet or external delivery leaves without an attorney’s approval and the export gate. (minimum: attorney)
- Nothing is deleted without a person confirming the deletion; legal holds refuse it outright. (minimum: person)
- A matter’s state (open, closed, on hold, archived) changes only when a person changes it. (minimum: person)
What this desk refuses
From the refusals catalogue (62 rows apply); the full catalogue is at /refusals.
Entering the attorney engines without the licensed-attorney attestation, the conflict answers and every acknowledgment.
Complete the attestation and the conflict screen; a flagged conflict is resolved by the attorney, not the software.
Running a paid desk without an active session, a trial allotment or a covering purchase.
Sign in, use the trial allotment, or purchase the matter.
Finalizing while any finding lacks a decision, or finalizing by anyone who is not an attorney.
Adjudicate every finding; an attorney records the finalization.
Representation of any kind: filing, service, negotiation with a party, or appearance, for anyone.
A licensed attorney represents; the platform prepares.
Drafting, reviewing or redlining a document for which no lawful exemplar lane is live.
Choose a document type with a lane, or wait on the named owner item (a keyed connector or a reviewed pack).
Output that lifts verbatim runs, or too much scattered overlap, from the exemplar filings.
The run is refused and reported; the engine drafts afresh on the same pinned exemplars.
Output that carries the exemplar filings' party names into the matter.
The run is refused and reported; the attorney never sees a foreign party in the draft.
A dual-engine consensus that swallows a material disagreement between the engines, or names it without binding a disposition to its issue id (a missing, duplicated or unknown id, a bare marker, or a conflict marked decided).
The divergence is carried as a decision card bound to its issue id; the attorney adjudicates it.
Delivering single-engine output when a dual run was purchased and one engine failed.
Retry, or run the standard lane knowingly.
Grounding a matter on a same-named county of another state.
The matter's own county tops the ladder; the run searches when the lane is thin.
Reaching a matter, review, draft, comparison or governed version that belongs to another tenant, or through a removed membership.
Work inside an active membership of the matter's tenant.
Reaching a matter the user is screened from, on any surface, including background execution.
The firm lifts the wall in the record; authorized colleagues keep their work.
Approving a governed version or adjudicating a finding without a licence record on file when the licence gate is on; administration alone never approves.
The firm records the attorney's licence; preparation by staff continues unaffected.
Sending a byte to a vendor outside the permitted list, over a non-https scheme, to a private network, or with a data class the vendor is not cleared for.
The owner reviews the constant; the surface reports the refusal instead of substituting a vendor.
Parsing an upload whose bytes do not match its declared type, whose archive expands beyond the fixed limits, or whose "text" is not text.
The receipt names the failed check; attach a genuine PDF, Word file or plain text.
Finalizing a version, exporting a final packet or delivering externally without a fresh confirmation bound to this actor, matter, operation, version and recipient, when the confirmation flag is on.
Mint a confirmation for exactly this act and spend it once.
A request path carrying a literal or encoded backslash, an invalid escape, double encoding or a control character.
Request the route as published.
Running on a document that names none of the matter's parties, or only a namesake, before the attorney decides whether it belongs.
Decide each flagged source by name (belongs to this matter, or exclude it from the run) and send the run again.
Attaching text for a scanned page the OCR engine could not read (too few words, or confidence too low to trust).
Rescan or photograph the page, or paste its text; the readable pages keep their text and their page anchors.
Reading a scanned PDF through the OCR lane on a deployment that has not turned the lane on.
Owner item: set FLAG_OCR_LANE=1; meanwhile photograph the pages or paste the text.
A dual-engine run whose second provider is missing, disallowed, or times out mid-run.
The typed failure carries the partial stage receipt (which branch ran, which did not, why); the fee was charged once at most; the attorney may separately elect a single-engine tier.
A requested attestation on the Certificate of AI Use that the audit trail contradicts, or that no recorded event supports.
Record the event the attestation needs (the attorney review, the check, the filing) and render the certificate again.
A change to a proposition's kind or disposition (promoting an allegation to a fact, accepting or rejecting a proposition) by anyone but an attorney.
A licensed attorney records the decision with its rationale; the proposition keeps its kind until then.
Opening a passage in a format that has no text locator (a spreadsheet, audio or video, an unreadable file).
Name the sheet and the cell, or the time code, by hand; the registry on /coverage lists every format and its locator.
A workflow requested for a state or task the coverage registry does not list as supported.
Use the workflow in a supported state, or the owner adds the state to the registry with its rights, version, evaluated output and owner first.
A finding, draft or decision whose source pins are missing, empty or malformed is not reported unchanged after a source moves; its review is blocked until the pins are read.
Re-run the record with its source versions pinned, or the attorney reviews the record against the current sources and decides again.
Finalizing or exporting a new artifact version on the strength of an approval recorded on an earlier version, or with a required finding undecided.
Decide every required finding, then record the attorney decision on the current version; the export follows the recorded approval.
A decision packet with a missing or unrecognized schema version on its envelope or any manifest, an unknown field, or missing required evidence.
Issue the packet again from the platform; the validator names each defect.
GET /api/verify/lookup answers no-record for every digest.
The owner decides the anchoring service; offline verification on /verify needs no lookup at all.
A component whose bounded probe did not answer reads unknown on /status and /api/status, never operational.
Wait for the next probe, or read the component's configuration and readiness columns, which are separate from the probe.
A vitals beacon carrying anything beyond the six coarse fields (route pattern, metric, value, device class, connection class, deployment id).
Nothing to do: the beacon the platform ships sends only the six fields.
Accepting a handoff as another person, or reading an unaccepted handoff as finished, or treating a reassignment as a grant of access or a transfer of approval.
The named receiver accepts; the reviewer decides on the pinned version; access is requested through the matter, never through a handoff.
Treating an owner, an admin or any role as a licensed attorney without an attested record with a bar identifier and a jurisdiction, or advertising an attested record as verified.
A firm owner records the attestation with the bar identifier and the jurisdiction; the record then reads attested, not verified.
A stored firm instruction that names or weakens a locked prompt (the injection guard, the UPL lint, the privilege and client-facing guardrails, the OCP standing orders, the dual-engine synthesis), or an instruction of a kind outside the permitted list.
Keep firm instructions to the house voice, terminology, formatting, the signature block and jurisdiction preferences.
Sending, sharing externally, finalizing, exporting a final packet, deleting or changing a matter's state without a person confirming that act, or confirming more than one such act in one approval, or a firm setting that lowers the floor.
Confirm each act on its own; raise the firm's confirmation level if the firm wants a second reviewer.
Serving a privileged document on an API key, or reaching a matter outside owner ∪ firm partition − screens ∩ allow-list.
Read the document as the attorney on the desk; the key reads ordinary and client-producible material only.
Minting, returning or accepting a confirmation token through the API, MCP, batch or any cancellation path; executing anything beyond a proposal.
Propose through the door; an attorney accepts the proposal to the rail on the desk, where the full gate stack runs.
Reporting a read as verified when any item in it is weaker, or reporting an unread table as empty.
Read the per-item statuses and the read_state; an unreadable read is retried or escalated, never treated as empty.
Answering a faulted read with an empty 200, or a failed check with a pass.
Retry after the store recovers; the response names the fault.
A webhook payload carrying content (text, a body, a quote, a title, a name), a log line, or a delivery to a private-network or non-https target.
Resolve the pointer through the API; register an https target on a public host.
A connector whose registry entry reads planned or pilot presented as connected, syncing or live anywhere.
Use the export and compose-link paths that are live today; the owner activates a connector on confirmed demand.
A retry that would re-send a done operation, or an operation whose other side answers a different matter than the recorded mapping.
A firm member corrects the mapping by name; the operation is re-queued only then.
Treating a passed biometric on the phone as server authorization, or extending a revoked session because the shell unlocked, or placing anything privileged on a lock screen or in a notification.
Sign in again; the shell opens but the desk waits for the server.
Deleting a matter, an account or a firm while a legal hold covers it.
The attorney or the owner releases the hold by name when it ends; the deletion then runs and produces its receipt.
Placing a legal hold without a reason or without a review date within a year.
Place the hold with its reason and a review date, and review it on that date.
Serving a restored database before the later ledgers are re-applied: a deleted row, a revoked share, key or grant, a superseded approval, or a job that would resume by itself.
Apply the post-restore actions and pass the verification; interrupted jobs are re-run only by a person.
A removed user reading, launching work or acting through a connector; identity recovery restoring more than the sign-in.
A firm administrator re-adds the member by name; a connector the user connected is taken over by name or revoked.
A procurement, trust or lifecycle document claiming a certification the platform does not hold (SOC 2 certified or compliant, HIPAA compliant, bank-grade and the like).
Read the controls with their evidence in the procurement package; a certification appears only after its report exists.
A published accuracy or outcome percentage without its count and denominator, or over a denominator too small to carry it.
Read the count and the denominator; the percentage appears when the denominator can carry it.
A claim that the platform outperforms a named competitor without a matched, blinded study on the same matters with its method published.
Compare what each product publishes; the benchmark reports this platform on its own terms.
Adopting or advertising an upgrade as better on fewer than twenty blind, versioned pairs, on an unmet margin, or with a serious regression.
Run more blind pairs; keep the preserved baseline in service meanwhile.
Selling a matter, a tier or an upgrade before the purchase-to-approved-export acceptance passed in controlled accounts.
Evaluate on the sample matter; purchases open when the owner records the acceptance and the activation.
A second grant, a second delivery or a revived benefit from a duplicate, reordered or post-refund event.
Support reconciles a quarantined purchase by hand from the provider record.
A saving, a return on investment or a projection presented as unit economics, or a price changed from the economics module.
Read the observed cost per accepted deliverable with its counts.
Opening the accounts door before the SMTP proof and the Auth switches, opening commerce before the acceptance, or treating the activation record as approved without the owner.
The owner reviews the record, chooses the cohorts and approves it by name.
Counting a configuration check, a keyless run that stops at the transport, or a DraftBench skip as live proof of a program.
The owner runs npm run live-proof with the keys in a session shell and commits the receipts.
A positioning statement that ranks, uses a superlative or disparages another product.
Read the positioning facts with their evidence and qualifications.
Building trust accounting, outcome prediction, deposition capture hardware, a public marketing-domain intake form, an in-house e-signature system or an autonomous litigation agent; or deleting a function because an expansion was declined.
Use the bounded answers: connectors, proposals only, the attorney-lane intake link, DocuSign under the firm’s credentials.
A procedure lens for a paper in another state's courts, a bankruptcy court or an appellate court.
Read the governing rules directly; the Theaters desk states the appellate and bankruptcy procedure.
Quoting rule text in the procedure lens.
Read each cited rule in its current official text.
A family lens on a locked preview, an unfinished review, another state's agreement or a paper that is not a family agreement.
Read the agreement against its own state's law.
Saying that an agreement's treatment of a topic is adequate, fair or enforceable.
Read the agreement against each statute and rule the lens names.
Inputs
- A PDF, Word file, plain text, photographed pages, or a scan read by the OCR lane
- The document type and governing state
- The purchased matter, carried in the link and the browser context from the last desk
Outputs
- A findings report with exemplar-grounded reasons
- The adjudication trail
- The Review Certificate once every finding is decided
- Word and PDF exports of the approved version
DraftCounsel is professional drafting software for licensed attorneys, operated by LegalDraft Technologies LLC. DraftCounsel is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. All output is AI-generated draft work product offered for attorney review; the supervising attorney is solely responsible for reviewing, revising, approving, and using any work product, and for compliance with applicable rules of professional conduct. Communications with DraftCounsel are not protected by attorney-client privilege.