Attorney review & decisions
Inspect the finding. Decide the language. Keep the record.
3 findings unresolved
Source: Opposing Counsel Pass™ · Motion to compel v1
Findings queue (3)
Review status
0 of 3 decided
Each finding requires a decision.
Relief exceeds the supported record
Finding 01 · IV. Requested relief
The index does not establish deliberate withholding. The proposed search scope still needs counsel’s decision.
Current text
Plaintiff requests an order compellingevery document concerning Defendant’s implementation work, from all custodians and systems, and finding that Defendant deliberately withheld responsive records.
Proposed text
Plaintiff requests supplemental responses and production of nonprivileged implementation records responsive to Requests 14 and 17, subject to the Court’s determination of the disputed scope. Plaintiff does not ask the Court to infer deliberate withholding from the production index alone.
Sources
A decision updates this finding only.
Proposed changes
01 · Relief exceeds the supported record
Plaintiff requests
an ordersupplementalcompellingresponseseveryanddocumentproductionconcerningofDefendant’snonprivileged implementationwork,recordsfromresponsivealltocustodiansRequests 14 andsystems17,andsubjectfindingtothattheDefendantCourt’sdeliberatelydeterminationwithheldofresponsivetherecordsdisputed scope. Plaintiff does not ask the Court to infer deliberate withholding from the production index alone.
Cite Check
A review runs no citation check, so nothing here was checked against authority. Cite Check checks the matter’s draft.
Open Cite CheckDecision record
No decision is recorded on this review yet.
The trail is append-only: a later decision is added, never written over an earlier one.
- Document approval: Pending
- Export permission: Pending
- Delivery: Not sent
Ask counsel
Helena Ashcombe
What supports narrowing the relief?
9:33 AM
DraftCounsel
Requests 14 and 17 and the September 4 conferral define the dispute. The proposal stays inside them and leaves out intent, which the index alone does not establish.
9:33 AM
Confirm the complete record before deciding.